Tonalists and Impressionists in Cos Cob: Unique American Views of the Connecticut Landscape

March 31, 2025

Event Details

Date: March 31, 2025
Time: 1:00 pm
–3:00 pm

The scenic Connecticut landscape has been the inspiration for artists for over a century. In a collaborative partnership with the Fairfield University Art Museum and the Bruce Museum, Greenwich Historical Society invites visitors from near and far to experience an exciting perspective on the American artists who shaped early modern American art and their portrayals of the landscapes around them.

A collaborative presentation will take place in the Greenwich Historical Society Permanent Collections Gallery with Mary Anne Hollihan, Curator of the Fairfield University Art Museum’s current exhibition, Dawn & Dusk: Tonalism in Connecticut, and Jordan Hillman, Curatorial Associate at the Bruce Museum and curator of the Nature’s Impressions exhibition. The presentation will conclude with an art colony tour of the National Historic Landmark Bush-Holley House hosted by Kathy Craughwell-Varda, Interim Curator at Greenwich Historical Society.

This event has reached capacity

Dawn & Dusk: Tonalism in Connecticut

Mary Ann Hollihan, Curator Dawn & Dusk: Tonalism in Connecticut Exhibition at University of Fairfield Art Museum

With the waning interest in the majestic landscapes of the Hudson River School during the late 19th century, new forms of art were taken up by a generation of artists who had studied in Munich and Paris and carried back to America techniques and ideas that they developed into uniquely American art forms. The intimate landscape views of the French Barbizon painters, together with the exhortations that art must bring about an emotional, not an intellectual response, led to the production of artwork we identify as tonalist.

In 1906, the critic Clara Ruge observed “We have today a national school of landscape painting which is rapidly advancing in importance and originality…A new school is, as it were, a new dialect in the language of painting. The vocabulary must be collected; the techniques must be studied.” Clara Ruge was talking about tonalism and spotlighted in her article the works of Connecticut painters, Leonard Ochtman, Henry Ward Ranger, Robert C. Minor, and Franklin de Haven. Connecticut painters were at the forefront of tonalism, a movement that persisted well into the 1920s.

Nature’s Impressions: Capturing Greenwich in Paint

Jordan Hillman, Curatorial Associate, The Bruce Museum

In an 1892 interview with Art Amateur magazine, Childe Hassam spoke to the essential relationship between art and nature but also between the artist’s eye and mind: “Art, to me, is the interpretation of the impression which nature makes upon the eye and brain. The word ‘impression’ as applied to art . . . really means the only truth because it means going straight to nature for inspiration and not allowing tradition to dictate your brush. . . . The true impressionism is realism.” While Hassam believes that artists should work directly from the landscape, he recognizes that ultimately it is their interpretation of it—their “impression”—that is translated from observed reality to its rendering in paint. Yet Hassam’s use of the term impression suggests more than a subjective, transitory artistic encounter with nature; it conjures a specific, modern style of painting associated, like Hassam, with French Impressionism.

This talk considers the impression that both the landscape of Greenwich and Hassam himself made on artists in late nineteenth-century Connecticut, inspiring those who boarded at the Bush-Holley House to innovate fresh stylistic and thematic approaches to nature. The shared ambitions and modern influences of these artists led to the formation of the Cos Cob art colony and, later, the Greenwich Society of Artists, which helped to redefine Impressionism as an American art form.

Art Colony Tour at Bush-Holley House

Kathy Craughwell-Varda, Interim Curator, Greenwich Historical Society

Tours of the Art Colony rooms of the Bush-Holley House will be provided to program participants. The tour will highlight the impact of the Holley-MacRae family boarding house on the artists and writers who stayed there and why it became the setting for the Cos Cob art colony. Josephine Lyon Holley and her daughter Constant Holley MacRae were skilled managers of the family boarding house which attracted artists, and writers to their charming 18th-century home set along the Mianus River. The picturesque setting and familial environment created by the Holley-MacRae’s provided a location that inspired the creativity of their borders and led to the first impressionist art colony in Connecticut.

During the tour visitors will be shown the locations in and outside the house that inspired the works of Twachtman, Hassam, MacRae, and more and see the artworks they completed in Cos Cob.

Speaker Biography

Mary Ann Hollihan

Mary Ann is an independent art historian with a specialty in 19th-century American painting and furniture. A Connecticut native, she lives and works from a farm in Canaan, CT. She attended the University of Pennsylvania, the University of Virginia Law School, and New York University’s Institute of Fine Arts in New York. After a spell practicing law, she returned to art history, working as a research associate at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, and eventually publishing a book on New York Federal furniture. She began collecting American paintings in graduate school and she and her husband Jack have amassed a significant collection of Hudson River School and tonalist painters as well as high style New York Federal furniture. Mary Ann recently curated an exhibition of tonalist paintings for the University of Fairfield Art Museum in Fairfield CT titled "Dawn and Dusk: Tonalism in Connecticut” which runs until April 12th and has received enthusiastic reviews.

Jordan Hillman

Jordan Hillman is a curatorial associate and the curator of Nature’s Impressions: The Modernist Landscape at the Bruce Museum. Before coming to the Bruce, she was an Annual Subject Fellow at the Centre allemand d’histoire de l’art, Paris. Previously, she was the International Fine Print Dealers Association Summer Fellow and curatorial research assistant in the Department of Prints, Drawings, and Photographs at the Baltimore Museum of Art. She received her PhD in Art History from the University of Delaware in 2023 with a dissertation that examined the ways in which artists subverted police authority through image-making in turn-of-the-century Paris, a subject she has explored in several publications.

Kathy Craughwell-Varda

Kathleen Craughwell-Varda started working in museums as a teenager due to her love of history and material culture. Since 2009, she has been the Director of Conservation ConneCTion, a program based at the Connecticut State Library that provides training and resources for museum and archive collection care. She is the creator of the Traveling Archivist and Traveling Curator programs. She is the creator and manager of the Museum Makeover grant program and the Collections Assessment Grant program in partnership with CT Humanities.

She began working at the Greenwich Historical Society in 1999, when she guest curated the exhibition, Mourning Washington. She co-curated the reinterpretation of the Bush-Holley House and curated the living quarters of the enslaved people. She led the project to inventory the museum collections for accreditation by the American Association for Museums, did several research projects on portraits in the collection, and guest curated seven exhibitions at the Greenwich Historical Society, including An Unfinished Revolution: The Women’s Suffrage Centennial, Sports! More Than Just a Game, and currently Greenwich During the Revolutionary War: A Frontier Town on the Front Line.